Gutman, Dan. 2006. THE HOMEWORK MACHINE. New York: Simon and Schuster Books for Younger Readers.
*Plot Summary
Four students unexpectedly become partners in crime and eventually even friends as they protect the secret of the homework machine.
*Impressions
The four fifth grade protagonists represent variety in family background, social status, and talent. Likewise, the characters take turns narrating the story, so a variety of viewpoints are represented in the book. With four people telling the story (two girls and two boys), most readers are likely to relate to the story. The characters are revealed through their versions of events and their interactions with one another, as well as their interactions with adults like teacher Miss Rasmussen and Police Chief Fish. The plot unfolds logically but must be pieced together using the narration of each character. The plot is made even more interesting because it involves a secret, relationships, and some elements of mystery. The resolution is both positive and plausible.
The setting is a modern day school near the Grand Canyon; its geographic location is an important part of the storyline. Because the story takes place in a school, many young readers will relate to the setting. The novel has a conversational tone with each character representing a unique voice and perspective. Just as the narration is varied so is the style including humorous, mysterious, and serious situations. The themes of the novel include friendship, cheating versus honesty, use of technology, death, and social status.
Overall, this novel is a great read. It is ideal for discussions about characters and point of view. With four diverse protagonists and several themes, I think many different upper elementary students would find the book satisfying.
*Review Excerpts
"The story is told entirely through short excerpts from police interviews. This device shows the developing relationships through the kids' own observations. There are touches of humor in the way the four classmates talk about themselves and one another. Ominous hints about the legal trouble maintain tension throughout the story, but its exact nature isn't revealed until near the end. A dramatic and thought-provoking story with a strong message about honesty and friendship."
School Library Journal
"This fast-paced, entertaining book has something for everyone: convincing characters deftly portrayed through their own words; points of discussion on ethics and student computer use; and every child's dream machine. Booktalkers will find this a natural, particularly for those hard-to-tempt readers whose preferred method of computer disposal involves a catapult and the Grand Canyon."
BookList *Starred Review
(Image from sequoiatimes.wordpress.com)
No comments:
Post a Comment